BD
FREE CONSULTATION
HOME/CRIMINAL CHARGES/BREACHES AND COURT ORDERS
ADMINISTRATION OF JUSTICE

Breach and Court Order Defence

Breach charges are the easiest offences in the Criminal Code for the Crown to prove and the most damaging to the case underneath them. A single missed condition can turn a manageable file into a detention order. They are also more defensible than most people assume, because the Crown has to prove the condition, the knowledge and the absence of a lawful excuse.

THE CHARGE

Why breach charges matter more than they look

A breach allegation does two things at once. It creates a new charge, and it undermines your position on the original one.

Failure to comply with a release order under section 145 and breach of probation under section 733.1 are both straightforward for the Crown to prove where the condition exists and the conduct is admitted. The consequence, however, is disproportionate. Bail becomes harder to obtain, the Crown hardens its position on the substantive charge, and any resolution that was available becomes less so.

That is why breach allegations should never be treated as minor administrative matters. They are treated by the system as evidence about you rather than about the incident.

Lawful excuse

The Code contemplates a lawful excuse, and the concept is broader than people expect. A medical emergency, an ambiguity in the wording of a condition, a genuine inability to comply, or conduct that police invited or facilitated can all support the defence.

The better answer is variation

Most breaches happen because a condition was unworkable from the start. A no contact term that ignores shared children, a residence condition that conflicts with employment, a curfew that makes a night shift impossible. Those conditions can be varied, and doing that early prevents the breach rather than defending it afterward.

THE CHARGES IN THIS GROUP

What you may be facing

Failure to comply with a release order, s. 145(4)
Any condition of a release order, from curfew to no contact to reporting.
Failure to attend court, s. 145(2)
Missing a date, which frequently follows a change of address or a missed notice.
Breach of probation, s. 733.1
Requires proof of the order, notice of it, and a wilful failure to comply.
Breach of a conditional sentence order
Administered differently, with its own hearing process and consequences.
Obstructing a peace officer, s. 129
Frequently laid alongside a breach allegation arising from the same interaction.
Breach of a firearms prohibition, s. 117.01
Serious in its own right, with substantial exposure.
THE BURDEN OF PROOF

What the Crown has to prove

Every element must be established beyond a reasonable doubt. If one element fails, the charge fails with it.

THE ELEMENTS
•
That the order existed and that the specific condition alleged was in fact part of it.
•
That the accused had notice and knowledge of the condition. Wording matters, and ambiguous conditions are read in favour of the accused.
•
That the conduct alleged actually breached the condition as written, rather than as the officer understood it.
•
That the failure was wilful, and on probation counts, that there was no lawful excuse for it.
•
That the accused is the person identified, which matters where the allegation rests on a phone call, a message or a third party report.
EXPOSURE

Penalties and consequences

On the new charge
A criminal record and, in aggravated cases, custody, even where the underlying matter would not have attracted it.
On bail
A breach makes any subsequent release far harder to obtain and can place the onus on the accused.
On the original file
The Crown’s position hardens and resolution options that existed before frequently close.
On probation
A breach can trigger revocation proceedings and resentencing on the original offence.
Cumulative effect
Repeated administration of justice charges create a record that follows you into every future bail hearing.
Immigration
Additional convictions compound consequences for non citizens.
Sentencing depends on the facts, the record of the accused and the position taken by the Crown. Nothing here is a prediction of the outcome of any particular case.
THE DEFENCE

Where these cases are challenged

These files turn on the precise wording of the order and on what the accused actually knew.

What the condition actually says

Conditions are frequently enforced as police understand them rather than as they are written. Reading the order itself, closely, resolves a surprising number of these allegations.

Notice and knowledge

The Crown must prove that you knew of the condition. Where an order was varied, mailed, or explained hurriedly at a courthouse counter, that proof is not automatic.

Lawful excuse

Emergencies, transit failures, hospitalisation, and situations where compliance was genuinely impossible are all capable of amounting to a lawful excuse when properly documented.

Whether the conduct falls inside the condition

Incidental contact, third party communication, and presence in a permitted area are all commonly charged and commonly not breaches at all.

•
Where a breach charge is defensible it should be defended, because the collateral damage of a conviction on the substantive file is often greater than the sentence on the breach itself.
HOW THE FILE IS RUN

What happens once you retain

•
Disclosure is requested immediately and read in full, including officer notes, audio, video and the continuity of every exhibit.
•
Release conditions are reviewed at the outset. Terms that make work, housing or contact with family unworkable can often be varied long before the case ends.
•
Legal issues are identified early, while there is still time to build a record for them.
•
The Crown is engaged from a prepared position. Resolution is pursued where it serves you, not because it is convenient.
•
You are kept informed throughout and you decide how the matter proceeds.
QUESTIONS WE ARE ASKED

Frequently asked questions

I breached a condition by accident. Does that matter?
It matters a great deal. The Crown must prove the failure was wilful, and on probation counts must negative a lawful excuse. Genuine accident and impossibility are real answers.
My partner contacted me and I answered. Am I in breach?
Very possibly, because the condition binds you and not them. This is one of the most common ways people are charged, and it is exactly why variations should be sought early.
Can I get my conditions changed?
Usually yes. Variations are frequently obtainable, often on consent, where the condition is unworkable and a sensible alternative is proposed.
Will a breach mean I go back into custody?
It is a real risk, particularly where there is more than one. Preparation for the bail hearing, including a revised release plan, is the priority.
Should I plead guilty just to clear it up?
Not without knowing what it costs on the main file. A breach conviction changes the Crown’s position on everything else, so it is assessed as part of the whole matter.
SPEAK WITH COUNSEL

Charged with this offence? Let us talk about it.

The first consultation is free and confidential. You will get a direct assessment of the charge, the process ahead, and what it will cost. Flat fees, payment plans and Legal Aid certificates are all accepted.

647.721.5150REQUEST A CONSULTATION
Available evenings and weekends. Reachable at any hour for an arrest in progress.

Request a Free Confidential Consultation

Speak directly with Kashif Alam. Your information remains strictly confidential under solicitor-client privilege.